Can iced coffee be stronger than an energy drink? Surprising findings from 13 product tests
EUFBA ·
Can iced coffee be stronger than an energy drink? In South Korea, one cold brew contained two and a half times as much caffeine per 100 ml as the strongest energy drink tested. A whole 2.1-litre bottle of coffee contained 630 mg of caffeine. In Germany, all 23 sports drinks tested met the conditions for the isotonic label, while none of the iced coffees assessed in Austria received a poor rating. These are some of the most interesting findings from 13 product tests in Europe, America and Asia.
We collected 13 product tests from Europe and beyond. We reviewed findings published by authorities, consumer organisations, newspapers and researchers, and summarised the most interesting results.
Iced coffee outpaced energy drinks
In South Korea, 57 ready-to-drink coffees were analysed. The cold brews contained 31–104 mg of caffeine per 100 ml. None of the energy drinks tested contained more than 40 mg in the same volume.
Hungarian results were similar. In official measurements, milk coffees contained up to 46 mg of caffeine per 100 ml, compared with up to 35 mg in energy drinks. Milk coffees varied considerably: the lowest result was 4 mg and the highest was 46 mg, a difference of more than tenfold.
One bottle, 630 mg of caffeine
Package size matters too. One americano tested was sold in a 2.1-litre bottle. It contained 30 mg of caffeine per 100 ml, amounting to 630 mg in the whole bottle.
For comparison, the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) considers that healthy adults can safely consume 400 mg of caffeine a day, counting all sources.
The South Korean investigation also checked labels. None of the 37 coffees analysed contained more than 120% of the caffeine amount declared on its label. All products also carried a high-caffeine warning.
Safety checks: no problems identified
Food safety authorities also test these drinks. In Hungary, for example, Nébih analysed 35 energy drinks. It reported no problems in any of the food safety aspects examined. The 23 drinks made with sugar contained the amount of sugar declared on their labels.
The authority also examined labels closely and identified labelling issues in 28 drinks. These concerned the information on the label, rather than the safety of the drink.
In an earlier investigation, the authority checked 28 milk coffees. It found no safety or quality defects, although 16 products had labelling issues. Tasters also assessed the coffees, with conventional and lactose-free products evaluated separately.
Vitamin drinks: laboratory results and labels
Vitamins presented the greatest challenge. In Slovenia, 50 fortified drinks were tested, with 244 comparisons between measured vitamin amounts and label declarations.
Of the measurements, 51.6% fell within the tolerance limits applied. Deviations occurred in both directions: 27.9% of measurements were below the declared amount and 20.5% were above it. On average, nicotinamide closely matched its label declaration, at 98.2% of the declared amount. The label provides information about the product, while a laboratory records the composition of the particular batch tested.
In Germany, consumer organisations reviewed the labels of 35 vitamin drinks. According to the labels, 25 drinks contained sugar and ten did not. The label therefore lets consumers see which type they are choosing.
Sports drinks: isotonic as labelled
A German magazine commissioned tests of 23 sports drinks. According to the measurements, all met the conditions for the “isotonic” label. The magazine’s own scoring system, which combined several criteria, awarded different overall ratings.
In Slovenia, 18 sports drinks sold as isotonic were analysed. Twelve fell within the isotonic range used in the study.
Which one was best?
Taste was assessed by tasting panels. In a US daily newspaper’s 2004 blind test, the four-member panel preferred the energy drink Pit Bull. In 2008, a Swiss television programme had experts taste ten milk coffees.
The Six Continents Index 2026, the largest energy drink assessment conducted to date worldwide, scored 151 energy drinks against 36 criteria. Without tasting, and based exclusively on ingredients, quality and transparency, it selected HELL Energy Classic (250 ml) as the world’s best energy drink.
Austrian consumer organisations assessed 30 chilled coffees: one received a “very good” rating, 11 were rated “good” and 18 “average”. None received a poor rating.
The takeaway
The drinks tested were found to be safe, but products varied considerably. Caffeine amounts can differ by as much as tenfold between products. For an informed choice, the label is the best starting point: it shows caffeine, sugar and package size. With highly caffeinated drinks, it is worth checking the whole package as well as the amount per 100 ml.
Important context
The 13 investigations took place in different countries and years and used different methods. Their findings apply only to the products actually tested, and formulations may since have changed. Older taste tests are historical examples. The EFSA reference value is not a consumption target and does not apply to children, pregnant women or breastfeeding mothers. This article is not a purchasing recommendation.
The review was prepared by EUFBA, a professional organisation in the beverage sector. It was not financed by beverage manufacturers.
Source: EUFBA (2026): Comparative product tests of energy drinks, sports drinks, vitamin drinks and iced coffees. doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24281531
EFSA’s caffeine reference value: EFSA (2015), efsa.europa.eu/en/efsajournal/pub/4102
Legal notice
This article is an accessible summary of the European Functional Beverage Association’s review, “Comparative product tests of energy drinks, sports drinks, vitamin drinks and iced coffees”. The narrative review analyses and summarises product tests previously published by third parties: authorities, consumer organisations, editorial teams and researchers. EUFBA did not carry out its own laboratory tests, measurements or tastings.
The data, ratings and rankings reported in this article come from the original publications. They apply only to the date, market, method and specific product variants examined in each investigation. They cannot be generalised to other products, variants or entire drink categories. The original publishers are responsible for the content, accuracy and completeness of their investigations; the data can be checked in the sources cited.
This article is for general information only. It is not advertising, commercial communication or a product or brand recommendation. It does not seek to encourage the purchase or consumption of any product, brand or drink category, or to influence perceptions of other products, manufacturers or distributors. Product names serve only to identify the variants assessed in the original investigations; their mention does not constitute a rating or recommendation by EUFBA.
The article makes no nutrition or health claims about foods and does not replace individual medical, dietary or other professional advice. When consuming drinks, always follow the information and warnings on the product label.
The article is based on information available on its publication date. EUFBA reserves the right to clarify or amend its content later.
