Comparative product testing of energy drinks, sports drinks, vitamin-fortified beverages and ready-to-drink coffee
EUFBA reviewed 13 original product assessments to explain why label data, laboratory measurements, sensory tests and composite scores answer different questions. The findings concern the product variants, markets and methods assessed.
Five numerical findings
| Finding | Numerical result | Scope |
|---|---|---|
| Caffeine in energy drinks | 13.8–40 mg/100 ml | Measured ranges across two separate studies, not a value applicable to every energy drink. |
| Osmolality of sports drinks | 23 of 23 and 12 of 18 products | Products meeting the respective tests’ different assessment criteria. Osmolality and sodium content are separate characteristics. |
| Measured vitamins versus labels | 244 comparisons; 51.6% within tolerance | 50 fortified products, including 29 vitamin waters; the percentage concerns vitamin–product comparisons. |
| Caffeine in ready-to-drink milk coffee | 4.0–46 mg/100 ml; 28 products | Concentrations measured in Nébih’s 2021 sample, not caffeine in the whole package. |
| Label comparison for ready-to-drink coffee | All 37 compared products below 120% of the label value | Cold brew and Americano samples included in the South Korean study’s label comparison; the complete study analysed 57 ready-to-drink coffees. |
Methods
A targeted multilingual search conducted on 15 November 2026 identified five journal articles and eight other original product assessments. The narrative review recorded the market, sample, measurement or assessment method and main finding. Laboratory results, label checks, sensory tests and organiser-defined scoring were interpreted separately.
Interpretation
Reporting the exact product variant, market, date, measurement unit and assessment method makes comparisons verifiable. Presenting label data, laboratory results, sensory ratings and composite scores separately shows which evidence supports each statement.
Limitations
The search used targeted source selection. There was no prespecified protocol, complete search count, duplicate screening or formal risk-of-bias assessment, so coverage cannot be estimated. Markets, years and methods differed; older sensory assessments are historical examples and formulations may have changed. Adding sample sizes does not establish the total number of unique product variants.
Authorship and disclosure
The original report was authored by EUFBA, a professional association representing the beverage sector concerned. Its disclosure states that beverage manufacturers did not fund preparation of the report. OpenAI ChatGPT and Anthropic Claude assisted source searching and manuscript editing; EUFBA is responsible for the content.
Original report and sources
The original report contains the complete references and source-by-source assessment. The PDF states that the report is available under CC BY 4.0; this refers to that report, not to rights in the third-party publications it cites.
