Original EUFBA article · · Study published: 28 December 2021; journal volume: 2022
Faster reactions? An Australian meta-analysis found a benefit in two small energy drink studies
An Australian research group pooled 14 studies on the relationship between nutritional interventions and cognitive performance. In the reaction-time analysis, a statistically significant benefit was found for energy drinks. This result came from two small studies, so its generalisability is limited, and it does not mean that an energy drink would outperform caffeine on its own in a direct comparison.
Liam S. Oliver and colleagues investigated nutritional interventions for cognitive performance measures relevant to sporting, military and aerospace settings. Led by Queensland University of Technology, the study was published in the International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health on 28 December 2021, as part of its 2022 volume. [1]
What did the researchers examine?
After screening more than 11,000 records and assessing 125 full texts, the researchers included 14 studies. They sought studies of healthy participants with mean ages between 18 and 45. Interventions used beta-alanine, caffeine, carbohydrate or energy drinks; comparable outcomes concerned response accuracy and reaction time.
The research was motivated by the literature on mental fatigue, but none of the included studies used an experimental intervention specifically designed to induce mental fatigue. The findings therefore do not establish that energy drinks eliminate mental fatigue. They provide information about measured reaction times and test results. [1]
Which finding was significant?
| Intervention | Number of studies | Pooled result |
|---|---|---|
| Energy drink | 2 | Statistically significant benefit |
| Caffeine alone | 5 | No significant benefit demonstrated |
| Carbohydrate | 4 | No significant benefit demonstrated |
| Beta-alanine | 2 | No significant benefit demonstrated |
The table shows the reaction-time analyses; the full review also included one additional caffeine study concerning accuracy. The energy drink analysis combined four effect estimates from two studies. The pooled standardised effect size was 0.64, with a 95% confidence interval of 0.13–1.16. This does not mean a 64% increase in speed; it is a statistical measure used to compare different tests. The width of the interval also indicates uncertainty in the estimate. [1]
For the other interventions, a non-significant result is not equivalent to proof of no effect. The number of studies, doses, mode of intake and timing of measurements differed. Results from separate subgroups alone cannot establish a ranking between energy drinks and pure caffeine.
What energy drinks were tested?
One study involved 15 trained cyclists. The drink tested contained 160 mg of caffeine, 54 g of carbohydrate, 2 g of taurine and ginseng. In the other, ten pentathletes received drinks containing carbohydrate, caffeine and guarana. Both studies included exercise and cognitive testing. [1]
These were complex interventions. The meta-analysis did not separate the effects of the individual ingredients, and exercise may also have influenced test performance. The result therefore applies to the drinks and experimental conditions studied; it cannot automatically be transferred to products with other formulations or to everyday tasks.
How strong is this evidence?
The researchers awarded the included studies a high average score on a modified methodological checklist. However, this does not change the fact that the energy drink finding rests on few participants and only two studies. A faster response in a computerised task does not necessarily mean better decisions during a match, at work or while driving.
The favourable reaction-time finding warrants further research. The authors called for larger, more carefully standardised randomised studies, particularly those that deliberately induce and measure mental fatigue.
The study declared no conflicts of interest. It disclosed that the first author received Australian Government Research Training Program and Queensland Academy of Sport scholarship support. [1]
Publisher and editor: EUFBA, an industry organisation. This article is a plain-language summary of the cited meta-analysis.
Sources
- Oliver, L. S. et al. (2022): Effects of Nutritional Interventions on Accuracy and Reaction Time with Relevance to Mental Fatigue in Sporting, Military, and Aerospace Populations: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 19(1), 307. DOI: 10.3390/ijerph19010307. Open-access full text.
Original EUFBA article · English editorial translation by EUFBA.
