Original EUFBA article · · Study published online: 14 December 2016; journal publication: February 2017
Better memory after one can? Newcastle researchers put it to the test
In an experiment involving 24 healthy young adults, two composite memory test measures were more favourable after a 250 ml sugar-containing energy drink than after its sugar-free version or placebo. Measurements were taken 30, 60 and 90 minutes after consumption. These are short-term test findings that cannot establish sustained memory improvement or the same effect for every energy drink.
Keith A. Wesnes and colleagues, with participation from Newcastle University’s NU-Food research facility and other institutions, compared the effects of a sugar-containing energy drink, its sugar-free version and a similarly flavoured placebo. The study appeared in the February 2017 issue of the Journal of Psychopharmacology and had been available online since December 2016. [1]
How was memory tested?
Twenty-four healthy young volunteers tried all three drinks on three separate days. The study used a randomised, double-blind, placebo-controlled crossover design. On each occasion, participants received 250 ml of drink, and testing was preceded by a standardised breakfast. Baseline measurements were taken before the drink, and the nine computerised tasks were repeated 30, 60 and 90 minutes later. [1]
The tasks assessed attention, working memory and episodic memory. Working memory is needed to hold and process information briefly; episodic memory supports recall or recognition of events and previously encountered information. Performance in the two domains was calculated from several tasks.
Which outcomes improved?
| Measure | Result for the sugar-containing drink |
|---|---|
| Composite memory accuracy | Significantly more favourable than the sugar-free drink and placebo |
| Composite speed of correct memory responses | Significantly more favourable than the sugar-free drink and placebo |
| Composite attention test measures | No clear advantage was demonstrated between the drinks |
The accuracy measure combined 12 accuracy measurements from six working-memory and episodic-memory tasks. The speed measure summarised the average speed of correct responses in the working-memory and recognition tasks. The main finding therefore concerns two composite measures; it does not mean that an improvement was found in every individual test. The authors described the differences as effects of a medium magnitude. [1]
Was it the sugar, the caffeine or their interaction?
One can of the sugar-containing drink tested provided 80 mg of caffeine and 1,000 mg of taurine. The sugar-free version also contained caffeine, yet did not produce the same memory results. This raises the possibility of a role for sugar and the combination of ingredients, but the research did not separate these effects. [1]
There was no separate condition providing the same dose of sugar without caffeine or the other ingredients. The study therefore cannot prove that sugar alone caused the improvement. The authors also discussed possible interactions between ingredients. The result for the sugar-free version does not mean that such drinks could have no effect with another product, dose or task.
What did the experiment not establish?
The study had a small sample, tested two versions of one particular product and used a short observation period. Measurements at 30, 60 and 90 minutes did not amount to continuous monitoring of memory. Regular consumption, sustained learning outcomes, workplace performance and long-term health effects were not examined.
The test findings suggest a possible short-term benefit in healthy young adults. They cannot be treated as evidence for every age group, every energy drink or a general memory-enhancing effect. The research also noted limitations in the detailed assessment of habitual caffeine consumption and in verifying prior abstinence from caffeine. [2]
Who funded the study?
According to the accepted manuscript published by Newcastle University, the CogTrack testing system is owned by Wesnes Cognition Ltd. The company provided financial support for the research and preparation of the paper; Keith Wesnes was the owner of the company. Newcastle University covered staff and research facility costs, while the company covered consumables and participant payments. This funding and ownership relationship is material information when evaluating the findings. [2]
Consumption decisions should also take total caffeine intake and individual sensitivity into account. EFSA’s single caffeine intake value of up to 200 mg for healthy adults is a safety reference, not a dose that promises memory improvement. [3]
Publisher and editor: EUFBA, an industry organisation. This article is a plain-language summary of the cited publications.
Sources
- Wesnes, K. A., Brooker, H., Watson, A. W., Bal, W. and Okello, E. (2017). Study topic: the effects of a sugar-containing and a sugar-free energy drink on cognitive performance and mood in healthy young volunteers. Journal of Psychopharmacology, 31(2), 211–221. DOI: 10.1177/0269881116681459.
- Newcastle University ePrints: accepted manuscript of the study. The downloadable manuscript describes the methodological limitations, funding and ownership relationship.
- EFSA NDA Panel (2015): Scientific Opinion on the safety of caffeine. EFSA Journal, 13(5), 4102. DOI: 10.2903/j.efsa.2015.4102.
Original EUFBA article · English editorial translation by EUFBA.
