Original EUFBA article · · Meta-analysis discussed: 2017; published online: 18 October 2016
Review of 34 studies: the energy drinks tested produced favourable results on several physical performance measures
In a 2017 meta-analysis, acute consumption of caffeine-containing energy drinks produced favourable results for pooled measures of strength and muscular endurance, endurance tests, jumping and certain sport-specific tasks. The pooled improvement in sprint performance did not reach statistical significance. The study associated higher taurine doses with larger performance effects, but this cannot establish the ingredient’s independent effect.
Diego B. Souza and colleagues combined the results of 34 studies published between 1998 and 2015. The Brazilian and Spanish researchers’ work appeared in the 2017 volume of the European Journal of Nutrition; it had been available online since October 2016. The research examined the effects of acute, short-term energy drink consumption on physical performance. [1]
What did the 34 studies show?
The authors searched PubMed, ISI Web of Knowledge and SPORTDiscus for studies up to December 2015. They used a standardised effect size, or ES, to make results from different tests comparable. This value is not a percentage improvement: it relates the performance difference to the variability of the measurements. The pooled analysis found the following results. [1]
| Performance measure | Effect size (ES) | Statistical result |
|---|---|---|
| Muscular strength and muscular endurance, pooled category | 0.49 | Significant benefit; p < 0.001 |
| Endurance tests | 0.53 | Significant benefit; p < 0.001 |
| Jump performance | 0.29 | Significant benefit; p = 0.01 |
| Sport-specific tasks | 0.51 | Significant benefit; p < 0.001 |
| Sprint performance | 0.14 | Not significant; p = 0.06 |
The value for strength and muscular endurance is the result for a combined category and should therefore not be interpreted as two separate estimates. For sprint performance, the positive average difference was not sufficiently convincing at the conventional statistical threshold. This does not prove that every individual sprint task is unaffected, but the pooled findings do not establish a definite sprint benefit either. [1]
Why did taurine attract attention?
The researchers also examined whether the size of the performance effect was associated with the doses of the drinks’ ingredients. In the comparison across studies, a higher taurine dose was associated with a larger performance effect (p = 0.04). No such statistically significant association was found for caffeine dose (p = 0.21). [1]
This meta-regression association is not equivalent to the result of an experiment that changes only the amount of taurine while holding every other ingredient constant. The products, participants and performance tests also differed. The association is therefore a finding that warrants further study, not proof of an independent taurine effect. The non-significant association with caffeine dose does not mean that caffeine is ineffective either.
The International Society of Sports Nutrition’s (ISSN) 2023 position stand considers the roles of caffeine and carbohydrate in the performance effects of energy drinks to have the strongest scientific support. It recommends further research to clarify any additional combined benefits of the other ingredients. The two documents address different questions and bodies of evidence. [2]
What do the findings apply to?
The meta-analysis summarises the results of several experiments, but does not eliminate the methodological limitations of the underlying research. Because the drinks, doses and tests differed, the average result is not a promise that every product will provide the same benefit in every sport. Performance following acute consumption also does not automatically establish long-term training adaptations or health effects.
Performance effects and safety are separate questions. EFSA considers single caffeine intakes up to 200 mg in healthy adults to raise no safety concern; this applies to all caffeine sources combined. Its conclusion concerning up to 400 mg spread throughout the day applies to healthy, non-pregnant adults. These are reference values, not doses recommended for sports performance. [3]
The meta-analysis authors declared no conflicts of interest. The EUFBA article Sports science consensus discusses a later professional assessment of energy drinks and sports performance.
Publisher and editor: EUFBA, an industry organisation. This article is a plain-language summary of external scientific publications.
Sources
- Souza, D. B., Del Coso, J., Casonatto, J. and Polito, M. D. (2017): Acute effects of caffeine-containing energy drinks on physical performance: a systematic review and meta-analysis. European Journal of Nutrition, 56, 13–27. DOI: 10.1007/s00394-016-1331-9. Publisher page and abstract.
- Jagim, A. R. et al. (2023): International society of sports nutrition position stand: energy drinks and energy shots. Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition, 20(1), 2171314. DOI: 10.1080/15502783.2023.2171314.
- EFSA NDA Panel (2015): Scientific Opinion on the safety of caffeine. EFSA Journal, 13(5), 4102. DOI: 10.2903/j.efsa.2015.4102. EFSA summary.
Original EUFBA article · English editorial translation by EUFBA.
